๐
On February 26, 2023, among other things, the White House announced that by the end of 2024, Tesla would open part of its US charging network, including Superchargers and Destination Chargers, to non-Tesla electric vehicles (EVs) and build significantly more charging stations that support all EVs.
Below is the portion of the announcement.
"Tesla,ย for the first time, will open a portion of its U.S. Supercharger and Destination Charger network to non-Tesla EVs, making at least 7,500 chargers available for all EVs by the end of 2024. The open chargers will be distributed across the United States. They willย include at least 3,500 new and existing 250 kW Superchargersย along highway corridors to expand freedom of travel for all EVs andย Level 2 Destination Charging at locations like hotels and restaurants in urban and rural locations.ย All EV drivers will be able to access these stations using the Tesla app or website. Additionally, Tesla will more than double its full nationwide network of Superchargers, manufactured in Buffalo, New York."
And that's great news. There's a good chance that many Tesla Superchargers will open up within a matter of days. Imagine you can charge your Polestar, Ford Mustang Match-E / F-150 Lighting, or any other EV quickly and conveniently on a long road trip!
If you wonder why Tesla is doing this, it's not out of the goodness of Elon Musk's heart. The company is set to get a big part of the 7.5 billion in government funding for EV charging. That's not to mention the company will make more money by selling electricity to non-Tesla drivers.
However, the devil is in the details, and things will get complicated for both Tesla and non-Tesla drivers, at least initially. The move to electrification is still in the early stages, and we have a long way to go.
Let's take a closer look at the current state of Tesla charging.
Existing Tesla Superchargers: Excellent yet near-sighted design
While Tesla drivers generally can get their cars charged at any non-Tesla Level-3 DC charger simply by using a CCS-to-Tesla adapter, the other way around is not that simple.
Getting a Tesla-to-CSS adapter is just a small part of the process. That's because Tesla has made its Superchargers only with its vehicle in mind and, even so, without a well-thought-out design.
When it "invented" the electric vehicle half a decade ago, Tesla had to figure out a new charging standard on its ownโthere had been none at the time since virtually no consumer-grade EV existed.
There were plug-in hybrid cars, but they were all for charging at home and hence didn't require a standard for public charging.
And over the years, the move has proved to be a competitive edge for Tesla. So far, thanks to the extensive charging network, it only makes sense to buy a Tesla if you expect to get charged reliably during a long drive.
The Superchargers are the reason many opted for the brandโyour truly included and have made many successful road trips with the 2021 Model Y.
If you're unfamiliar with EV charging, the drawer below will fill you in with some quick highlights.
EV Charging levels in brief
Two main charging connection standards currently exist for EVs in the US, including the Combined Charging System (CCS) and Tesla, as shown in the photos below.
And there are three EV charging levels. The tabs below contain their brief information.
Level 1 EV Charging: 120V (up to โ 15A)
- Electricity: Alternating current (AC).
- To-car connectors: J1772, NACS (Tesla).
- Charging rate: 3 to 5 Miles Per Hour (โ 1.5 kW).
- Applicability: Home or anywhere with a 120V wall socket.
Level 1 charging is the lowest and, in the US, generally means you plug the car directly into a 120V outlet using the car's default (often included) portable charger, technically called electric vehicle service equipment or EVSE.
There are also third-party portable chargers. While varying in design, costs, and possibly quality, all chargers will work with all EVs. It's just a matter of getting the right adapter when necessary.
These "chargers" are essentially power cords. The charging function is inside the EV.
Apart from the 120V socket, most level-1 chargers also work with 240V sockets to deliver faster Level-2 charging speed.
Until April 17, 2022, Tesla included the Mobile Connector with its cars. It's the company's default Level-1 Charger.
Level 2 EV Charging: Up to 240 V (up to โ 80A)
- Electricity: Alternating current (AC).
- To-car connectors: J1772, NACS (Tesla).
- Charging rate: Up to 80 Miles per Hour (โ 20 kW).
- Applicability: Home or anywhere with a 240V wall socket or a charging station.
Level-2 charging is the fastest option you can install at home. It requires new wiring.
At the minimum, in the US, you'll need a separate breaker for a 240V outlet, similar to an oven or dryer. Most EVs' portable chargers work with 240V and 120V outlets via interchangeable to-wall adapters.
A charging station, such as the Tesla Wall Charger, requires new wiring. This type of charger must be wired directly into a 240V breaker and won't work with any socket.
Level 2 can deliver between 15A to 80A of electrical flow and give an EV up to 80 miles in an hour of charging though 60 miles/hour is common.
Level 3 EV Charging: At least 400 V
- Electricity: Direct current (DC).
- To-car connectors: Combined Charging System (CCS) and NACS (Tesla).
- Charging rate: at least 3 miles per minute, up to over a thousand miles per hour.
- Applicability: Public charging station.
Level 3 charging equals "gas stations" for EVsโit's the fastest charging option.
For years, Tesla's Superchargers have been the most well-known Level-3 charging, with each charger capable of filling a Tesla's battery from 20% to 80% in 20 minutes, or as fast as 5 minutes, depending on its wattage, which ranges from 75 kW to 250 kW (and even higher.) The higher, the quicker the charging rate.
In the US, most, if not all, non-Tesla Level-3 charging stations use the CCS connector, which encompasses the J1772 connector.
Many non-Tesla DC chargers include a Tesla connector.
Level 3 charging uses direct current (DC) instead of alternating current (AC), like in the case of Levels 1 and 2. Each charger costs tens of thousands of dollars. That's not to mention the electricity cost.
Other than CCS, some Japanese cars also use a new connection called CHAdeMO for Level-3 charging. In the US, a CHAdeMO DC charger often includes a CCS and a Tesla connector.
Before Tesla opens up its Superchargers to all EVS, only Tesla drivers need an adapter to get their car juiced at a non-Tesla charger. There are two adapters, as shown in the photos below.
But it's safe to say the whole public Supercharging network of Tesla has been designed without much thought, from the super short charging cord to the layout of the charging station itself.
The super-short charging cord and non-drive-through design
All Tesla cars have a charging port at the same locationโon the driver's side toward the back. And the Superchargers are made to accommodate that designโits charging cord is long enough.
Back your Tesla to a charger, plug the cord in, and you're done. And the majority of the time, that works perfectly.
But life can be messy, and sometimes we carry more than just what the car can haul on the inside. And that's when things get complicated.
You'll find the cord too short if you tow a trailer or even have a hitch rack with a couple of bicycles. You cannot charge without removing stuff from the car's back unless you can take over a few adjacent chargers.
With EVs becoming increasingly popular, you shouldn't count on finding an empty charging station. Things will only get worse on this front.
And that's the cause for Teslas themselves.
Non-Tesla EVs will be problematic by default. That's because most of them have the charging ports at different spots from a Teslaโarbitrarily all over their bodies.
So opening up Superchargers to them will turn any Supercharging station into a serious mess of car parking, whichever way blocking chargers adjacent to the one being used.
And that's when you realize the design of the Supercharger stations doesn't help.
All gas stations use the drive-through design allowing cars to be refilled orderly. Superchargers use the parking stall designโlikely to accommodate the original expected long charging time.
This layout can cause traffic issues during high usage since vehicles need extra maneuvering to get in and out. That, plus the short charging cord, will turn a Supercharging station chaotic when few non-Tesla EVs are involved during busy hours.
All hours will be peak hours
It's safe to say most Tesla owners won't be happy sharing Superchargers with other car brands.
Currently, during off-peak hours when the cost of charging is slow, you can already find long lines at Tesla charging stations in big cities. That's only going to get worse.
Folks who have bought Teslas thinking that comes with the "privilege" of using the Superchargers will be frustrated. The idea of waiting to get my Model Y charged at a Supercharger during a trip is quite off-putting.
During high demand, Tesla limited the level a car can charge to increase turnover, effectively increasing how frequently the EV needs to get charged during a long trip.
And ultimately, that'd make all hours at the charging station peak hours. You'll have to pay more in getting charged via high energy costs, wait time or both.
Charging at home is the best
Owning an EV generally means you'll charge it mostly at homeโthe most convenient and cheapest optionโand nothing will change on this front.
Home charging uses only Level-1 or Level-2 charging, and if you want to plug a non-Tesla vehicle into a Tesla charger, all you need is a Tesla-to-J17772 adapter.
The takeaway
The opening of Tesla's Supercharging network is excellent news for non-Tesla EV drivers in the US who can take a long road trip without range anxiety overnight. That's if they are equipped to deal with the potential connection and design problem mentioned above.
And for Tesla drivers, once the whining is over, they'll realize that they've already gotten it both ways for a long timeโall Teslas can be charged at non-Tesla chargers. It's only fair to share and, most importantly, to realize that Teslas are just vehiclesโyou're not riding on the extension of Elon Musk's ego.
Ultimately, everything is in implementation. Hopefully, new charging stations, Tesla or not, will use a more accommodating design that works for all EVs of different shapes and charging port locations. Who knows, Tesla might even retrofit its existing facilities with longer charging cords or readily available extended Tesla-to-CCS converters.
Eventually, we'll get to the point where getting charged on the road is a non-issue, just like getting an ICE car's gas tank filled. It's only a matter of time.
While Tesla will set your charging to only 80% at peak times, you can change it and charge to whatever you want–but most people don’t.
Since you’re also in the Bay Area, I’d be curious for a followup on this article in a year or so as well as your own personal experiences. ๐
Check back in a year, or sooner, and you might be in for a surprise, Samir. ๐