Monday, August 15, 2022 β€’ Welcome to the πŸ’― No-Nonsense Zone❗
πŸ›οΈ Check out Today’s πŸ”₯Amazon logoDeals! πŸ›’

Synology DS1522+ Review: A Fresh (yet Familiar) and Excellent 5-Bay NAS Server

Share what you're reading!

Synology’s latest 5-bay DiskStation DS1522+ NAS server for homes and small businesses is a silent yet significant upgrade in the lineup.

While the new server is the intended replacement of its immediate previous model, the DS1520+, I will compare the design with the DS1517+ to show how it’s an (almost) complete “leap” in hardware.

This brief review will focus on this novelty and what that means. In the grand scheme of things, the DS1522+ is another familiar and excellent NAS server, but you should look at it as $880 hardware instead of a $699.99 one as its retail price (disk-less) suggests.

Confused? Let’s find out what I mean.

Dong’s note: I first published this post on Jun 29, 2022, as a new piece and updated it to an in-depth review on July 20 after thorough hands-on testing.

(This post was originally and exclusively published at Dong Knows Tech.)

Synology DiskStation DS1522 Back
The most significant yet subtle difference of the new Synology DiskStation DS1522+ is on its backside. Note the little area where you can quickly upgrade the server to 10Gbps capability via the all-new E10G22 T1 Mini module.

DiskStation DS1522+: 6th time is the charm

Generally, Synology releases its 5-bay DS15xx Plus server every two years, starting with the DS1511+ that came out in 2011.

Per the NAS maker’s naming convention, the DS15xx+ is the Plus 5-bay lineup for homes and SMBs that can house up to 15 drives. Five on its own and another ten via two expansion units.

The company skipped the 2019 model year. After that, we had the DS1520+. And now the latest DS1522+ is the 6th generation in the product line.

Other than the 2020 model, I’ve tested all DS15xx servers, starting with the DS1511+, and in my experience, this lineup is the most well-balanced.

With five native drive bays, the DS15xx gives users the option to run multiple RAID setups, including RAID 6, and good flexibility in network storage. And the ability to expand to 10 drive bays more is a good option, just in case.

Synology DS1522 system infoSynology DS1511 system info
Here are the Info Center pages of the DS1522+ (left) and the DS1511+ — both running with their original amount of RAM. These pages are different mostly because the former run DSM 7 while the latter, which I’ve been using since 2011, is stuck at DSM 6.2.

I’ve owned and I’m still using/managing many DS15xx+ servers, including DS1511+, DS1513, DS1515+, and DS1517+ in various capacities. I skipped the DS1520+ upon finding out it was similar to the DS1019+, which I have also been using.

The table below will show you the slow hardware evolution of this lineup.

DS1522+DS1520+DS1517+DS1515+DS1513+DS1511+
Model Year202220202017201520132011
Gigabit Port444444
Dimensions16.6 x 23 x 22.3 cm16.6 x 23 x 22.3 cm16.6 x 28.2 x 24.3 cm15.7x 24.8 x 23.3 cm15.7x 24.8 x 23.3 cm15.7x 24.8 x 23.3 cm
USB Port2x USB 3.02x USB 3.04x USB 3.04x USB 3.02x USB 3.0,
4x USB 2.0
4x USB 2.0
CPU2.6 GHz AMD Ryzen R1600 Dual-Core
(4-Threads)
2.0GHz Intel Celeron J4125
Quad-Core

2.4 GHz Intel Atom C2538 Quad-Core
2.4 GHz Intel Atom C2538 Quad-Core2.13 GHz
Intel Atom Dual Core
1.8GHz
Intel Daul-Core
RAM8GB
(Expandable to 32GB)
8GB
(Expandable to 20GB)
2GB
(Expandable to 16GB)
2GB
(Expandable to 6GB)
2GB (Expandable to 4GB)1GB
(Expandable to 3GB)
Built-in NVMe M.2 slot
(caching)
22NoneNoneNoneNone
PCIe slot
(upgrade)
NoneNone
1x 8-lane PCIe slot
NoneNoneNone
Upgrade
Options
Synology E10G22-T1-Mini
(1x 10Gbps BASE-T)
NoneSynology E10G21-F2 (2x SFP+ port)
Synology E10G18-T1 (1x 10Gbps BASE-T)
Synology E10M20-T1 (1x 10Gbps BASE-T, 2x NVMe M.2 slot)
NoneNoneNone
The evolution of Synology DS15xx lineup in brief

In terms of physical design, the DS1522+ is basically the DS1520+ plus the new Network Upgrade Slot. Compared to the DS1517+, the new server does away with the PCIe slot.

Synology DiskStation DS1522 vs DS1517 and updater cardsSynology DiskStation DS1522 vs DS1517 backside
DS1522+ vs DS1517 (bottom): Note the two servers’ 10Gbps upgrade option, the former’s new 10Gbps BASE-T E10G22-T1-Mini module, and the clunky 2x SFP+ E10G21-F2 PCIe card of the later. The omission of the PCIe slot allows the DS1522+ to be slightly more compact.

DiskStation DS1522+: Lots of improvements

From the table above, you’ll note that DS1522+ differs from previous servers.

Specifically, it’s the first that comes with NVMe M.2 slots to host two solid-state drives for caching and the option to upgrade to 10Gbps Ethernet.

The NVMe SSDs can’t work as regular storage volumes.

Previous servers only have one of those options or none at all.

The new and easy 10Gbps upgrade module

Most importantly, the 10Gbps-capable upgrade now comes in the form of a Network Upgrade Slot to house the new E10G22-T1-Mini module that Synology launched simultaneously with a new server.

Synology E10G22 T1 Mini 10Gbps update cardSynology E10G22 T1 Mini adapter
The E10G22-T1-Mini 10Gbps module and its retail box

For now, this module only features a single 10Gbps BASE-T port and fits only the DS1522+. However, future servers will likely also have this slot, and chances are we’ll find SFP+ modules or those with more than two ports going forward.

For now, though, the new server has no SFP+ or dual 10Gbps Ethernet option, which can be a deal-breaker for those needing one.

It’s worth noting that the new 10Gbps module is proprietary and will only work on supported Synology servers. However, going strict on hardware support has been the Synology way. The clearest sign is DSM 7 where third-party USB dongles are no longer supported. While this approach increases the cost, it improves stability.

The E10G22-T1-Mini has the current street price of $180 — which will fluctuate based on demand — comparable to a PCIe card for the DS1517+. Considering Multi-Gig networking is a must for a server, you should look at the DS1522+ as an $880 server with the option of not going 10Gbps for less.

Tip

If you add the E10G22-T1-Mini module or any 10Gbps upgrade card to your server, make sure you don’t use it for the initial setup process. Pick one of the server’s built-in Gigabit ports instead.

A Synology server will not recognize any add-on supported hardware until after its operating system has been installed.

Multi-Gig: What it is and why it’s hot right now

The Ryzen migration

The second most important thing to note is that, like the case of DS1821+ or DS1621+, the DS1522+ now uses an embedded AMD Ryzen CPU, the R1600 dual-core running at 2.6 GHz, with the max boost clock of up to 3.1 GHz.

In my experience, AMD Ryzen is much more powerful for daily computing than Intel Atom or Celeron CPUs, which were widely used in previous models. The new AMD CPUs elevate these home and SMB servers’ capability, making them more comparable to Synology’s enterprise models running Intel Xeon chips.

In return, AMD CPUs generally don’t have built-in GPU resulting in the fact they are not as good as Intel chips in handling video streaming — there’s no hardware support for 4K transcoding.

However, due to the ubiquity of flexible playback software — such as VLC, which is available on all platforms –, the lack of media transcoding on the server side is no longer a huge issue.

Since the DS1621+, I’ve turned off hardware transcoding on the server side and let the frontend playback software take care of everything. With that, I’ve been able to stream 4K videos hosted on my server using the Synology Video Station on any device, even when traveling.

Since 2021, almost all new home and small business NAS servers from Synology have used AMD chips. This trend is likely to continue.

DSM 7.1 out of the box

The DS1522+ is the first in the family to run DSM 7.1 out of the box — previous servers originally came with DSM 6.

While this means you won’t be able to run some legacy apps with it, the latest OS has much better performance and a more streamlined user interface.

Most noticeably, with DSM 7.1, the DS1522+ is also the first server that features Surveillance Station 9.0 — you can use up to 40 IP cameras with it. The new app, per Synology, features simultaneous dual recording to C2 Surveillance cloud storage.

Surveillance Station 9.0 Review: What it is and why it’s been one of the best DIY home security solutions

Synology DiskStation 1522+: Detail photos

Synology DiskStation DS1522out of the box
Out of the box, the Synology DiskStation DS1522+ includes everything you’d need to get it up and running — you just have to add the storage.

Synology DiskStation DS1522drive bays
Like the case of most, if not all, Synology NAS servers released in the past decade, the DS1522+ has five front-facing drive bays, each having a lock to keep it in place. The server has two keys for the job, but you can also use a screwdriver when necessary.

Synology DiskStation DS1522 with HDDs
The familiar tool-free design: Each drive tray has two latches to keep the hard drive in place. You can assemble a 3.5-inch (desktop) drive to the server without a tool.

Synology DiskStation DS1522 with SSD Installation
If you use 2.5-inch hard drives or SSDs, a screwdriver is needed. In this case, the included bag of little screws will come in handy.

Synology DiskStation DS1522 M.2 NVMe SSD slots
The DS1522 M.2 comes with two M.2 slots on its underside to host two NVMe SSDs for caching.

Synology DiskStation DS1522ports wihtout 10Gbps
Here’s the back of the Synology DiskStation DS1522+. Note its four Gigabit network ports and the Network Upgrade Slot that’s covered up.

Synology DiskStation DS1522 with
It’s straightforward to upgrade the Synology DiskStation DS1522+ to 10Gbps. All you have to do is get the upgrade module (not included) and install it into the slot.

Synology DiskStation DS1522with E10G22 T1 Mini being installedSynology DiskStation DS1517with SFP upgrade
The upgrade process is much faster than the case of the DS1517+ (left) or any server with a PCIe slot, where you’d have to open up the server’s case for the job.

Synology DiskStation DS1522after E10G22 T1 Mini
Here’s a 10Gbps-capable Synology DiskStation DS1522+ server.

Synology DiskStation DS1522Power adapter
The Synology DiskStation DS1522+’s power adapter

Synology DiskStation DS1522+ vs DS1520+: Hardware specifications

DS1522+DS1520+
CPUAMD RyzenTM R1600 dual-core (4-thread) 2.6 GHz, max. boost clock up to 3.1 GHzIntel Celeron J4125 4-core 2.0 GHz, burst up to 2.7 GHz
System Memory8GB DDR4 ECC SODIMM8 GB DDR4 non-ECC (4 GB onboard & 4 GB SO-DIMM slot)
Max Memory32GB via two memory slots 
(16 GB x 2)
20GB via one memory slot 
(16 GB + 4GB)
Dimensions166 x 230 x 223 mm166 x 230 x 223 mm
Weight2.7 kg2.62 kg
Drive Bays55
Expansion SupportYes (two units)Yes (two units)
Drive InterfaceSATA 6Gbps/3Gbps; 
Hot-swappable
SATA 6Gbps/3Gbps; 
Hot-swappable
Built-in M.2 SlotsTwoTwo
RAID TypesSHR, Basic, JBOD, RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 5, RAID 6, and RAID 10SHR, Basic, JBOD, RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 5, RAID 6, and RAID 10
Ports / Interfaces4x RJ-45 1GbE LAN, 
2x USB 3.0, 2x eSATA
4x RJ-45 1GbE LAN, 
3x USB 3.0, 2x eSATA
PCIe ExpansionNetwork Upgrade SlotNone
Add-on Hardware
(not included)
E10G22-T1-Mini 10Gbps-BASE-T moduleNone
Operating SystemDSM 7.1 (and later)DSM 6.2 (and later)
File System (Internal / External)Internal: Btrfs, ext4
External: Btrfs, ext4, ext3, FAT32, NTFS, HFS+, exFAT (via app)
Internal: Btrfs, ext4
External: Btrfs, ext4, ext3, FAT32, NTFS, HFS+, exFAT (via app)
Number of IP Camera Support
(for Surveillance Station)
4040
Camera License22
MSRP (Disk-less)
(at launch)
$699.99$699.99
Warranty3 years3 years
Sinology DiskStation DS1522+ vs DS1520+: Hardware specifications

Some old remains, a familiar server at heart

But not everything about the DS1522+ is new.

The server still features now-legacy eSATA ports to host expansion units instead of the latest and much faster Mini-SAS HD, like the case of the higher-end DS2422+.

eSATA has a ceiling speed of just 5Gpbs, which will be the bottleneck for each expansion unit’s five drives. But in return, you can use the more affordable DX517 instead of the 12-bay DX1222 to expand the storage.

In my experience, if the included 5 bays are not enough, it is better to get a server with more native bays, such as the DS1621+ or DS1821+, or upgrade to larger hard drives. Using expansion units, or USB ports, to add more storage is clunky and might create more points of failure.

Other than that, you can expect the new DiskStation DS1522+ NAS server to have all the goodness of any Synology server, including a robust operating system and tons of valuable add-on packages, as I detailed in this primer post.

NAS server: What it is and why you’d want to get a Synology today

Synology Drive Optimization
Even with DSM 7.1, Synology servers generally take a long time to optimize a newly built RAID setup — in the example, the process for an SHR of three 8TB hard drives would take about a day. The process runs in the background, slowing down the server’s general performance.

And there is some familiar badness, too:

For example, when setting it up with a few large hard drives, you’ll note that the server takes a long time to finish “optimizing” the RAID.

Specifically, the process, which can’t be canceled, took about a day for my three 8TB hard drives in an SHR setup, during which the server worked at slower performance. The similar “data scrubbing,” a recommended periodical maintenance, also takes an incredibly long time to finish.

And like all other Synology servers, the DS1522+ includes only two IP camera licenses, although it can handle up to 40 cameras for its Surveillance Station — each additional license costs some $60 apiece. And you can’t transfer these two to any other server.

But for the most part, the new server has a lot to offer. So much that I’m not going to touch everything it can do in this review. That’d take too long.

Like a computer, the new DS1522+ shares the same feature and apps as others that run Synology DSM 7. The box below includes a short list of the server’s apps and features.

Synology’s common apps and features

These apps and features are generally available across Synology servers that run DSM 7. These are just some examples. There are more than 100 official apps and many more from third parties.

Synology Active Backup for Business (ABB): Consolidate backup tasks for virtualized environments, physical servers, and personal computers, and rapidly restore files, entire machines, or VMs – completely license-free.

Synology Chat: Aimed at businesses, Synology Chat is an IM service that transforms how users collaborate and communicate.

Synology Drive: Host your own private cloud behind the safety of your NAS with 100% data ownership and no subscription fees.

Synology Download Station: Search and download content from the web via a few clicks, no computer is required.

Synology Calendar: Stay on track, share calendars, and schedule meetings while ensuring sensitive information remains safely stored on company premises.

Synology Moments: Manage your photos and videos with deep-learning algorithms that automatically group photos with similar faces, subjects, and places.

Synology Office: Create documents, spreadsheets, and slides in a multi-user environment. Real-time synchronization and saving make collaboration.

Synology Hyper Backup: Backup your NAS safely and efficiently to multiple destinations with deduplication, integrity checks, compression, and versioning.

Synology Surveillance Station: A DIY tool for safeguarding home or business via video surveillance tools.

Synology Virtual Machine Manager (VMM): An intuitive hypervisor that supports Windows, Linux, and Virtual DSM virtual machines. Its powerful disaster recovery tools help users achieve maximum service uptime.

Synology High Availability: Synology High Availability (SHA) combines two Synology NAS servers into one active-passive high-availability cluster, alleviating service disruptions while mirroring data.

Synology Central Management System (CMS): Synology CMS allows you to manage multiple Synology NAS servers quickly and conveniently from a single location.

Synology Video Station: Manage all your movies, TV shows, and home videos. Stream them on multiple devices or share them with friends and family.

Synology Photo Station: Built to help photographers manage their photos and share them with clients for feedback or business development.

Synology Audio Station: Manage your music collection, create personal playlists, stream them to your own devices, or share with family or friends.

Synology File Station: Manage your Synology NAS files remotely through web browsers or mobile devices.

You can migrate to the DS1522+ from any existing server by moving the internal drives over. One thing to remember: The new server doesn’t support DSM 6, nor does it feature the old ext3 file system. Before the upgrade, make sure you first change the existing server’s file system to the Btrfs file system.

DiskStation DS1522+: Excellent performance

For this review, I’ve used the DS1522+ for a week — I will continue to use mine for years to come — and the sever performed as expected.

It was reliable, quiet, and fast. In terms of throughput, it was on par with other high-end servers I’ve reviewed, including the DS1821+ and DS1621+, as you will note in the chart below.

I used a large file (some 100GB) for the tests and copied it between the server and a computer equipped with a 10Gbps network card and the fastest PCIe Gen 4 NVMe SSD. I used no NVMe caching for the tests.

Synology DiskStation DS1522 Performance
The Synology DiskStation DS1522+’s performance

I tested the server with two SATA SSD in RAID 0 and SHR (similar to RAID 1 in this case) and three hard drives in SHR (equivalent to RAID 5), using a Gigabit or a 10Gbps connection. In the best-case scenario, the server sustained at almost 800MB/s, almost as fast as the speed of a 10Gbps connection after overhead.

Synology DiskStation DS1522+'s Rating

8.8 out of 10
Synology DiskStation DS1522 with Box no a Table
Performance
9/10
Features
9/10
Design and Setup
9/10
Value
8/10

Pros

Fast and reliable performance, easy 10Gbps network upgrade

DSM 7 native with lots of useful home and business applications

Straightforward and consistent setup, upgrade, and management

Built-in M.2 NVMe slots

Lots of network storage options

Quiet operator

Cons

Legacy eSATA for storage expansion; NVMe SSDs only work for caching

Only two camera licenses included

Expensive to upgrade (RAM, 10Gbps module, etc.) due to proprietary approach, no SFP+ option

Conclusion

In more ways than one, the DiskStation DS1522+ is a minor incremental upgrade in Synology’s DS15xx lineup.

But looking at the product family, starting with the oldest unit, the DS1511+, this new server proves to be a sizable upgrade. It’s a new server with impressive novelties while maintaining the familiarities we’ve come to expect from the storage vendor.

If you’re looking for a new NAS server today, the DS1522+ is a safe and excellent buy — make sure you also get the E10G22 T1 Mini module.

But if you’re using a server that can run DSM 7 and don’t yet need 10Gbps Ethernet, or if you’re happy with Link Aggregation, for now, this new router is not a must-have.

Share what you just read!

Comments are subject to approval.

It's generally faster to get answers via site/page search -- your question/comment is one of many that Dong Knows Tech receives daily. Β 

  1. Strictly no bigotry, profanity, trolling, violence, or spamming -- including unsolicited bashing/praising/plugging a product/brand (β€’).
  2. You're presumed to have read this page in its entirety, including related linked posts and previous comments -- questions already addressed will likely be ignored.
  3. Be reasonable, attentive, and respectful! (No typo-laden comment, please!)

(β€’) Per the πŸ’―no-nonsense policy, all comments with an external link are scrutinized, and most links are redacted. Do not leave a comment if you're, in any capacity, representing a company/product mentioned here! Instead, send Dong Knows Tech a private message or use a PR channel.

Thank you!

8 thoughts on “Synology DS1522+ Review: A Fresh (yet Familiar) and Excellent 5-Bay NAS Server”

  1. Dear Dong,
    Up to this moment, my DS1520+ with 500GB x2 NVMe SSDs, but after my test, it seems hasn’t been any improvement in bootup and data transfer.
    I take off the 500GB x2 NVMe SSDs, and I feel is the same.
    Would you please let me know what is different? ^^

    Reply
  2. Why can’t they use standard PCIe slot? Because they want to sell their ridiculously priced 10gbe modules for 2x to 3x the price of 10gbe PCIe cards.

    The cheap price factor is nullified with dumb module’s price.

    Reply
      • I can get a 10gbe pcie card for $99. I can use any card the linux kernel supports. So big fail there when it comes to proprietary module. When I have two 10gbe cards lying around, it makes more sense to buy a NAS which has a proper pcie port for upgrade.

        Reply
        • And you can still buy models that support your cards. But Synology has gone this proprietary route for a long time, selling add-on cards and RAM of its own and only offers warranty and support for those. The company even removed the support for all third-party USB dongles starting with DSM 7.

          Reply
  3. Do you think there is a chance that the synology ds222+ will sport an AMD ryzen chip? That would make it quite a nice upgrade

    Reply
    • I’m not sure if they will make one this year, Moe, but the next release of the Dual-bay server will likely run an AMD chip.

      Reply

Leave a Comment