Wi-Fi vs. Internet: How to Best Troubleshoot Your Home Network

A typical some Wi-Fi network setup: A router connects to a modem via its WAN (internet) network port.

We tend to only care about our home Wi-Fi network when there’s no Internet. Ironically, it’s also when we can’t go online to search for solutions. So it’s a good thing you’re reading this now when you’re still connected.

You’ll find in this post the common networking terms you should know, simple troubleshooting steps for any Wi-Fi network, and the most effective way to get help.

Before continue, though, you might want to check out this post on how to build your home network from scratch to understand different parts of a home network.

Troubleshooting a Wi-Fi network: Understanding the lingoes

When it comes to home networking repair, it’s vital to find out exactly what goes wrong, and where. Else, you might waste a lot of time trying to fix what that’s not broken. Knowing the differences between common hardware parts save you time and frustration.

The following are a few that often get mistaken for one another.

Wi-Fi vs. the Internet

Wi-Fi is generally synonymous with Internet access because it’s the most popular way for mobile devices to get online. But they are two different things.

Wi-Fi: The wireless alternative to network cables

That’s correct. Before Wi-Fi, network cables were the only way to connect devices within a local network (LAN). So, in a way, you can see Wi-Fi as invisible network cables. Well, you can’t see it, but you know what I mean.

A Wi-Fi broadcaster (a router or access point) broadcasts wireless signals for Wi-Fi clients (smartphones, tablets, laptops, etc.) to catch on to create connections. It’s like you’re throwing an invisible network cable from the router to each client.

In a local network (like your home), the Wi-Fi router (or router for short) is responsible for creating the entire local system and keeping devices connected. As long as your router works, your local services are available.

As a result, you can print to your network printer, make Time Machine backups, play music to your Wi-Fi speakers, or stream content from your home server, and so on, even when there’s no Internet access.

The takeaway on Wi-Fi: You can have strong Wi-Fi yet can’t get online at all. Also, if your router is down — like unplugged — then you can’t get online at all even when the Internet is fine.

Internet: Stuff outside of your home

The Internet is the connection between many local networks (including yours), big and small, which is why the Internet is also called a wide area network (WAN).

Generally, in a home, the Internet connection is the job of a modem. A modem allows only one device to connect to the Internet.

For this reason, we need a router, which hooks to the modem and redistributes that single Internet connection to multiple devices within the home network simultaneously. This distribution takes place via regular network cables or Wi-Fi. You can read more about this in my post about IP addresses.

READ NOW:  What Is an IP Address and How to Figure out Yours

That said, as you’re reading this right now, chances are the device you’re using currently connects to the router of your local network. That router connects to a modem, and that modem connects to the Internet.

The takeaway on the Internet: You can have the Internet without Wi-Fi. In this case, your computer needs to connect to the modem via a network cable.

Cellular vs. Wi-Fi vs. mobile hotspot

When you use your smartphone’s cellular connection (4G LTE or 5G), it’s similar to using a single device with a modem. Specifically, the phone itself is a computer that has a built-in cellular modem. In this case, the phone connects directly to the service provider’s network and hence, the Internet.

The status screen of a typical mobile hotspot.

It’s important to note that all smartphones also support Wi-Fi. There are many instances your phone connects to both a cellular network and a Wi-Fi network at the same time.

In this case, you’ll see two signal indicators on its screen at the top right or top left corner, depending on the phone. The vertical signal indicator is that of the Wi-Fi network, and the horizontal is that of the cellular network.

By default, a phone generally chooses to use Wi-Fi to connect to the Internet before it uses its mobile signal. In other words, if Wi-Fi is available, you won’t use up your cellular data plan.

And a mobile hotspot, such as the Verizon Jetpack 8800L, is actually a mini gateway. Indeed, it’s a tiny Wi-Fi router that has a built-in cellular modem.

The hotspot connects to the Internet via its modem and then redistributes that connection to multiple devices via its integrated Wi-Fi broadcaster. By the way, most smartphones can also work as a mobile hotspot, in a mode called “Personal hotspot”.

That said, when you are using a mobile hotspot in an area without cell reception, you can still have strong Wi-Fi on your device, but yet can’t connect to the Internet. That’s a typical example of how Wi-Fi is different from the Internet.

And in this case, you shouldn’t blame Wi-Fi for the fact you can’t go online.

Restart vs. reset

Folks tend to mistake these two terms for each other, and that can be dangerous.

Note the reset button on the backside of this Netgear Orbi router.

Restart (or reboot or re-power) means you turn your device off and then turn back on. You can do this via the power switch or by unplugging the power cable and then plugging it back in.

You generally don’t need a tool to perform a restart. Restarting the router and modem often helps fix some connection problems. Just like a computer, a router needs to restart once in a while.

Reset is a more complicated process that might require a pointy object to do and will erase all the settings of a networking device. Since a network needs specific settings to work, mistaking a restart for a reset can cause big problems.

The reason for the mix-up is because technicians often call a restart a soft reset. (And they use hard reset for a reset). Then “soft” is omitted, and that’s where the problem begins. That said when a support representative asks you to reset your router, make sure you clarify before you do anything.

Now that we’re clear on the basic terms, let ‘s move on to the fun part of troubleshooting a home Wi-Fi network.

Steps to troubleshoot your Wi-Fi network

Every Wi-Fi network is different. Most importantly you need to know if yours consists of a modem and a router, or a gateway. To find out which is which you can consult this post on home networking hardware.

But with all of them, you can apply these steps when you don’t have a Wi-Fi connection, or have no access to the Internet. A lot of times, the issue is minor and requires as little as a restart of the router, or modem.

1. Take care of the basics

  • If you can’t go to a particular website, try a few different ones to see if they work. Sometimes, the specific site, or service, you want to use is down, and that has nothing to do with your home network or the Internet. You just have to wait it out, or call the service itself for status.
  • Make sure you haven’t accidentally turned off the Wi-Fi on the device. This tends to happen with laptops where you can turn the Airplane mode on by accident. Then give the device a restart.
  • Make sure your device connects the correct Wi-Fi network (and not one of your neighbors, for example.) Connecting to a wrong Wi-Fi network will cause local tasks, like printing or file sharing, to fail.
  • Check the cables. They should be plugged-in correctly and are intact (not broken or chewed up by pets).
  • All hardware devices (router, modem, gateway, switches, etc.), need to be plugged into power and turned on. You need to see some lights coming out of them.

2. Figure out where the issue is

When all the cables are in good shape, now it’s time to find out where the problem is.

If you can see your Wi-Fi network being broadcast, chances are your router is working well.
If your Wi-Fi network is available, chances are your router is working well.

a. Can you connect to your Wi-Fi network? If you can’t, or your network is unavailable — you don’t see its name appear on your phone — then the issue is the router.

b. If you can connect to your Wi-Fi network — your computer or phone indicated that there’s a Wi-Fi connection — but you cannot access the Internet to check email or Facebook — then the issue is likely at the modem.

In any case, you can always start with the modem.

3. What to check on the modem

The modem is literal your connection to the Internet and it needs to be in good shape. There’s one particular status light that you need to check on and here are what you should do at the modem.

Note the Internet light on the cable modem (right) which needs to be on solid for your broadband connection to work well.
Note the Internet light on the cable modem (right), which needs to be on solid for your broadband connection to work well.

a. Give the modem a restart, then wait a few minutes for the modem to fully boot up. That might fix the problem. If not go to the next step.

b. Find Internet status light. Every modem (or residential gateway) has one. This status light might be labeled differently (Internet, online, signal, or sync) but almost always has the icon of a little globe.

This light needs to be on solid (green, blue, or white). If it’s off or red, then make sure the service cable is intact and not loose. If that doesn’t fix the issue, check to make sure there’s no outage in the area.

c. If nothing works and there’s no outage, it’s time to call your provider, at this point, there’s nothing you can do. Tell the customer support agent that you have no Internet signal at the modem, they’ll know what to do.

4. What to do at the router

There are a couple of things you can do with the router.

a. First, give it a restart and wait a few minutes, that might fix the issue. If not, continue.

b. Check the network cable connecting the router’s WAN (Internet) port and the modem to make sure it’s plugged in securely at both ends. Also, make sure the Wi-Fi function is not turned off –many routers have an on/off switch for Wi-Fi. If that doesn’t fix the problem, continue.

c. At this point, you’ll need to do a bit more work. Try accessing the router’s web interface. Try updating its firmware to the latest. That will take a bit of time, and it might fix the problem. If not continue.

d. Access the router’s interface gain. This time, back up its settings, then reset it — yes, I do mean reset — and set up your network from scratch (or restore it from the backup file).

If you can’t access the interface or don’t know how to reset it using the interface, you can reset it via the reset button. If all that doesn’t solve the problem, it’s time to get a new router or professional help.

Wi-Fi troubleshooting: How to get help

When you call for help, the person on the other end will try to troubleshoot the problem. You should tell them exactly what has happened instead of what you think has happened. Also, describe the issue instead of its consequences.

For example, instead of saying, “I can’t get online,” explain what happens when you try to go to a website or check email. Give the person the error message.

Or, instead of “My Wi-Fi is not working,” describe what happens when you try to connect, or if your Wi-Fi network is not available, etc.

It’s also helpful to take and share photos of the error messages, and the device’s status lights. Visual is always useful when it comes to troubleshooting.

Dong’s note: I first published this post on Jan 18, 2019, and updated it on February 28, 2020, to add more relevant information.

4 thoughts on “Wi-Fi vs. Internet: How to Best Troubleshoot Your Home Network”

  1. I am so happy I found your blog and I absolutely love your information about the internet and wi-fi trouble shooting.I liked and it is wonderful to know about so many things that are useful for all of us! Thanks a lot for this amazing blog!!

  2. This article provides us information regarding internet and wi-fi trouble shooting. I loved the way they have researched and presented it infront of us. Here you will get to know in detail about the topic which are in demand. I enjoyed alot while reading this article and would recommend other.

  3. I have been having that problem intermittently for the last couple of months and Comcast has been unable to fix it. I was thinking maybe it was my computer. Thank you so much for writing this article. I printed it out and will try to follow it.
    Thank you for your help-you have helped me before and I really appreciate it!

    Best, Marsha


Leave a comment below. (Subject to approval. No spam or profanity, please!)