Wi-Fi has become so popular that nowadays, getting a router without it, a non-Wi-Fi router, can be a challenge.
This post will include the best five options among standard routers without built-in Wi-Fi I've tested. They are the true representatives of the original meaning of the word "router."
If you're wondering why you'd want one in the first place or what a standard router has to do with a Wi-Fi network, you're reading the right post.
Let's dig in!
Why a non-Wi-Fi router?
Technically, a Wi-Fi router is a standard router with a Wi-Fi access point (WAP) included within the same hardware box. This convenient design works well when you only need one Wi-Fi broadcaster that you can place anywhere you want within your home for optimal coverage.
The problem is, in real life, you generally need to place the router where the Internet terminal enters the property. In most homes, the Internet drop is not the ideal spot to place the Wi-Fi broadcaster. Since the signals come out from the router like a sphere, the coverage is off-center, rendering many parts of the home Wi-Fi "dead zones".
For this reason, separating the Wi-Fi access point from the router gives you the flexibility for optimal hardware placement: You put the router unit near the terminal device and the Wi-Fi access point near the center of the area of desired Wi-Fi coverage with a network cable linking the two.
You can use a Wi-Fi router plus another broadcaster, which is the case for most canned mesh systems or extenders, but that's not ideal in terms of cost and signal quality due to interference.
The point is that getting a non-Wi-Fi router is the fitting option in many homes where the Internet drop is in the basement or at a corner. In this case, you can run a network cable to the center of the house and put a Wi-Fi access point there instead of having it at the same location as the router.
Important: This type of setup is applicable only in a home already wired with network cables or to those who are willing to run one cable or two manually, which can be a fun weekend project.
Top five best non-Wi-Fi routers: The list
Below is the list of the top five best non-Wi-Fi routers you can bring home today, ranging from the most recommended to the least. I'll also include their wired networking grades and recommended access points to use with each.
Top 5 best non-Wi-Fi Routers
Name | Ubiquiti Cloud Gateway Max's Rating | Ubiquiti UDM-SE's Rating | Asus ExpertWiFi EBG15 Router's Rating | EnGenius ESG510's Rating | Amazon eero PoE Gateway's Rating |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Price | - | - | - | - | - |
Rating | |||||
Description | |||||
Statistics | |||||
Buy this product |
1. Ubiquiti Cloud Gateway Max: 2.5Gbps Multi-Gig router
The Cloud Gateway Max is the latest UniFi console from Ubiquiti that can do much more than just a standard router. For example, it can be the NVR for an IP camera surveillance system, the controller for an IP phone system, and more. And it can do that all at the same time. That, plus the compact design and excellent performance, makes its $199 price tag (no storage) a steal.
The Cloud Gateway Max works with any access point, but it's designed to host those from the same UniFi family.
Ubiquiti Cloud Gateway Max's Rating
Pros
Excellent entry-level Multi-Gig performance for a comparatively low-cost
Compact and aesthetically pleasant design with powerful hardware to handle a home or small business networks via multiple simultaneous enterprise-class application
A complete set of useful networking features, including powerful security/web-filtering and WireGuard VPN; excellent web user interface; useful mobile apps
No subscription is required
Cons
No 10Gbps ports or built-in PoE
Ubiquiti login account is required for convenient remote management and mobile apps
Runs a bit warm, no SSD caddy is included in the non-storage version
2. Ubiquiti UniFi Dream Machine Special Edition (UDM-SE): A 10Gbps-ready PoE+ router
The UDM-SE is literally a rackmount version of the Cloud Gateway Max above. It's a much larger UniFi console with more power and higher capacity for a large home or a big office. It, too, is an excellent standard router, among other capabilities, well worth its $500 retail price. Alternatively, you can opt for the Dream Machine Pro Max.
Like the Cloud Gateway Max above, the UDM-SE can work with any access point, but it's designed to handle those from the UniFi family.
Ubiquiti UDM-SE's Rating
Pros
Powerful enough to run all Ubiquiti's business hardware segments simultaneously
Reliable and fast multi-Gigabit performance with robust Dual-WAN support
A complete set of useful networking features, including powerful security/web-filtering and WireGuard VPN; excellent web user interface; useful mobile apps
Built-in PoE support; comparatively affordable; no subscription required; quiet
Cons
Single Multi-Gig (2.5GBASE-T) port; limited multi-Gigabit LAN options; no PoE++
Requires an account with Ubiquiti for mobile apps and remote management to work; not wall-mountable; runs a bit hot
3. Asus ExpertWiFi EBG15: A Gigabit router
The EBG15 is the first standard router within Asus's new ExpertWiFi family. It's a tiny router with lots of advanced features for home and business users alike. When coupled with Asus's AiMesh router or access points, it'll be the host of a robust Wi-Fi network, making its sub-$90 price tag a great deal.
Asus ExpertWiFi EBG15 Router's Rating
Pros
Super-compact and feature-reach with a robust web user interface
Part of the ExpertWiFi family with lots of advanced features, including Software-Defined Networks and powerful VPN options
Excellent optional ExpertWiFi mobile app; can handle up to 4 WAN connections simultaneously
Cons
No Multi-Gig or PoE ports; no built-in Wi-Fi
Single main SSID when hosting an AiMesh broadcaster
4. EnGenius ESG510: 2.5Gbps PoE+ router
The EnGenius ESG510 is a standard business routerโit represents many other options, such as the Firewalla Gold, without a built-in controller for Wi-Fi access points of the same ecosystem. Still, it has a built-in firewall, PoE+ ports, and four 2.5Gbps ports, enough to be well worth the current $300 street price. You can use it with any standard access points, though in this case, it's best to use those with a centralized controller, such as the Omada or EnGenius FIT lineups.
EnGenius ESG510's Rating
Pros
Simple and straightforward to set up and use
Four Mult-Gig ports with Dual-WAN, PoE+ support
EnGenious Cloud Basic (free) has everything a home or SMB network needs with a helpful Cloud-to-Go mobile app
Compact, practical design; runs cool
Cons
A bit pricey; zero customization with the built-in local web interface
The online portal requires a login account; no 10GBASE-T or SFP+ option
Requires some networking know-how to set up and manage
5. Amazon eero PoE Gateway: A 10Gbps PoE++ router
The eero PoE Gateway is an excellent piece of hardware thanks to its two 10Gbps ports and eight 2.5Gbps PoE+ ports. Unfortunately, it runs a firmware that's very thin on features and settings while constantly nagging for the Eero+ subscription. If you only care about building a 10Gbps network, it's still a decent option to consider, especially when you also want to go with the eero access points.
Amazon Mesh with eero PoE Hardware's Rating
Pros
Two auto-sensing 10GBASE-T ports and eight PoE++ 2.5GBASE-T ports on the router and a 2.5GBASE-T POE port on the access point to deliver true multi-Gigabit wired performance
Compact design, easy to use
Good coverage, reliable performance
Cons
Expensive with extremely limited customizability and privacy risks
No web user interface (or desktop app) or command line support; no common business features, such as VLAN; all useful features (Dual-WAN, VPN, QoS, Parental Controls, etc.) require the eero Plus subscription
The router's internal fan is a tad noisy; runs very hot
The takeaway
There you go. Above are the current non-Wi-Fi routers you can bring home today. Depending on your needs, each will give you the flexibility of building a Wi-Fi network with optimal hardware arrangement and cost.
Give this approach a try, and by that, I mean get your home wired, and you'll find a satisfying home network on the other side.
I have Asus EVG15 and it is a bag or hurt. Itโs firmware is beta, the UI is slow and clunky and ingeneral the firmware is just unfinished.
Firewalla?
I mentioned the Gold I reviewed, which represents the brand well. It’s more of an add-on device than a real router.
MikroTik 5009 is a nice little wired router, esp. for people who want to learn the finer points of networking
It’s similar to the ESG510 mentioned here, which has no built-in controller for any APs.
What about Omada routers? Curious how they fare against the list here. Thank you!
They likely will do well with Omada APs, though they can be overwhelming. I haven’t reviewed one yet.